Our clients
Flight Path Dance Project
How to go from start-up to long-haul?
Fundraising
Founded in 2018, Flight Path Dance Project established its first company of dancers in 2019. Just as they were creating a community, dance program, and the systems that would support them, the pandemic started. From their inception, they have needed to be agile and creative about their organization's sustainability. Now, we're working together to shift into a place of proactivity in their fundraising and visioning work. Together we will:
segment and assess giving data
create year-long fundraising plans that can adapt to changing realities
align communication with donor needs and culture
St. Michael’s Episcopal Church
How do we create a stewardship plan in the midst of a transition in leadership and a presidential election?
Annual campaign
We've been brought in to help St. Michael’s reflect on how they think about and organize their annual campaign as they navigate a pastoral transition.
Alongside each other, we're working on:
developing an infrastructure for donor record data segmentation
providing guidance in aligning data analysis with giving strategies and formation
coaching leadership in the creation of a theme for their annual campaign
developing a plan for ongoing tracking and coaching of volunteers
Presbytery of Southern New England
What do we do with church buildings made for a different time and place?
We’re providing support for presbytery leadership, and working with three congregations exploring land and property possibilities. We've organized this complex work into two phases.
Phase I: congregation + property assessment
assess the needs and opportunities in the three individual congregations
engage in congregational and community listening
communicate with member churches about potential property strategies
Phase II: theology, core values + strategic filter
articulate a theology of land and property that is rooted in their context
discern core values that will reflect that theology
develop a strategic filter for property decision-making based on these values
St. David’s Episcopal Church
Is it a good time to raise money during a leadership transition?
Fundraising, strategy + vision
St. David’s hired an interim rector after a long-term pastorate while they engaged in a call process. Transitional periods present opportunities to reflect on how things have been done, assess what has been working, and make plans for future change.
Our work with St. David's includes considering stewardship practices because when done well, fundraising provides opportunities to strengthen relationships, create a robust year-round ministry, deepen commitments and articulate a vision for the future.
Together, we are:
developing an infrastructure for donor record data segmentation
providing guidance in aligning data analysis with giving strategies and formation
examining individual and collective money narratives, as well as training volunteers for annual giving, at an on-site retreat
creating a plan for growth potential to prepare for annual giving
developing a plan for on-going tracking, education and management of volunteers
St. John the Evangelist
How can our buildings be used for the repair of our community?
Phase I: listening
St. John’s is discerning the potential for a capital campaign. To prepare, we first led a process to foster healthy relationships with money. We unpacked individual and collective money narratives and deconstructed dominant systems of power and control as they relate to financial resources.
During this listening process, we:
facilitated a congregational-wide survey that asks questions around individual and corporate money narratives, in addition to asking questions around potential capital projects and how they connect with St. John's identity
led a day-long, in-person retreat to explore money narratives
interviewed community partners to understand how St. John’s is perceived and also what areas of future partnership might be ripe for exploration
provided a report that is rooted in their faith community’s context with recommendations for future practices regarding a holistic relationship
Insight Meditation Community of Western Massachusetts
How does an organization move away from a shoestring budget?
Fundraising, strategy + vision
Mieke started working with IWM as we were coming out of the pandemic. This community was asking big questions around the nature of their future, how to increase fundraising practices, and how to communicate their need. We engaged in a coaching relationship which included:
leadership of a strategic visioning retreat
creation of a timeline and assisting in implementation for a fundraising campaign celebrating their 25th anniversary
data segmentation
articulating and transitioning money narratives
training volunteers
planning for a new year
St. Mary’s Episcopal Church
As we grow, what holds us together?
Phase I: listening
In recent years, St. Mary’s has experienced significant identity shifts between a change in long-term leadership, the pandemic, and shifting wider cultural norms. We worked with St. Mary’s to help articulate to what makes their community unique, and explore what might be in store for the future. In our listening process, we:
worked alongside a core team
organized and conducting focus groups
wrote and reviewed surveys — analyzed data and reflected back what we heard
made recommendations for next steps
Saint Andrew’s Episcopal Church
How do we make decisions that reflect who we are?
Core values + strategic thinking
Leadership at Saint Andrew's understands that — given rapidly changing cultural understandings and expressions of faith and religiosity — churches are best served by articulating the core of who God is calling them to be in the world, and by making decisions consistently based on those values. We worked with leadership to:
articulate their core values
lead a Vestry retreat to practice the work of collective decision-making based on those core values
translate their core values into a strategic filter for the entire congregation to utilize so that every decision, no matter what the scale, can be rooted in this parish's most meaningful shared beliefs
utilize their new strategic filter to evaluate three areas of their life together — such as stewardship, buildings and grounds, and programming
Ascension School Camp and Conference Center
How do you engage in a feasibility study with multiple partnerships at play?
Phase I: feasibility
We worked with leadership to understand if and how, through collaborative partnerships, they could raise funds for capital projects that would transform their facilities, impacting campers and their families and conference attendees, as well as the local community at-large. Our feasibility study laid the foundation for a healthy capital campaign. In this phase of our work together, we:
honed in on and articulated the vision for a potential capital campaign
created spaces for listening to current and potential donors, as well a variety of stakeholders (campers and their families, conference attendees, diocesan contacts, several community partners, and neighbors in Cove) to understand what is important to them and where their concerns or resistance may lie
created opportunities for relationship-building and strengthening of partnerships for a common cause
determined the quantifiable level of financial support that can reasonably be anticipated for the proposed projects and determine a feasible fundraising goal
The feasibility study showed 100% support for a capital campaign (a first for us!) and excitement to get started immediately.
Phase II: solicitation
This capital campaign is one of the entire diocese, as well as the community of Cove, OR. We will begin by raising funds for the pool, which will be open to the entire Cove community, and also used for camp. Kickoff for this is at Cherry Fair, a day where people come from all over the region for a "family-friendly day of old-fashioned fun, music, and food" on the grounds of Ascension School.
We then turn to the diocese by kicking off at the convention in the fall of 2024. A series of "Come and See" events will take place where all members of the diocese are welcome to come and experience Ascension School, and the magic it offers that just can't be communicated through words.
All in, we are working to raise funds for the pool, the endowment to care for the costs of the pool, and to build the organizational endowment for long-term sustainability.
The solicitation phase of capital campaigns requires dozens of volunteers, dedicated staff time, and imagination. Walking alongside them we are leading the campaign through:
writing and designing the case statement ← check it out!
event planning
tracking of gifts
training and coaching solicitors
creation of strategy as the campaign unfolds
Episcopal Church of the Nativity
How do buildings reflect a church’s theology?
Feasibility study
To be one body, Church of the Nativity is considering a capital campaign to make their buildings accessible to all bodies. We worked with this community on a feasibility study to determine next steps toward making their buildings reflect their theology. Together, we identified:
the projects that rank highest in importance to congregants
the level of financial support and volunteer support leadership can expect from the congregation
best practices for communication and education if a capital campaign is planned, so the process is engaging and transparent
money narratives at play among congregants that will be important for leadership to keep in mind as they navigate fundraising
Christ Episcopal Church
How can fundraising transform a church's relationship to its downtown community?
Phase I: feasibility
As leadership considers capital improvements, they seek to understand what it means to be a part of a reawakening community, and how working together for the common good includes their congregants and neighbors alike. We worked with this congregation on a feasibility study to determine the level of support for a campaign that would:
create a new entrance hall to improve accessibility, visibility and welcome
expand their performance space and pub to accommodate and expand communities who gather there for artistic programming and more
renovate their parish house with a commercial kitchen and accessible restrooms to expand welcome and hospitality to all
refresh outdoor spaces to demonstrate gratitude for God’s gift of the land that they steward
National City Christian Church Foundation
How do we navigate complex governing structures?
Feasibility + fundraising
National City Christian Church’s neoclassical building in Washington, DC requires significant work. Their donor base is both local and national, as the building is actually owned by the denomination and yet inhabited by a local congregation. Alongside leadership of the Foundation, we worked on their year-end fundraising and in conducting a feasibility study to understand their fundraising potential and possible roadblocks. Our work included:
coaching on creation of team and structure for feasibility study
creation of project budget
board facilitation
writing and design for end-of-year fundraising letter
writing and design for feasibility case statement
creation of feasibility infrastructure
receipt of surveys and conducting interviews
data analysis
creation of comprehensive report for next steps
Episcopal Diocese of Missouri
What do we do with a previously successful program when the world around it has changed?
Strategy + vision
In an on-going effort to ensure the program was meeting the needs and priorities of the Diocese of Missouri, Bishop Deon Johnson placed a pause on the program and engaged Vandersall Collective in August of 2022 to perform a review. This review included:
a document review of over 300 pages of founding documents
19 stakeholder interviews
creation of a diocesan-wide survey of delegates
data analysis
competitive analysis of the field
comprehensive report with recommendations for short and long-term next steps
UKirk SMU
How do we sustain connection as so much changes?
Phase I: feasibility
We conducted a feasibility study to explore possibilities in establishing their own place of belonging. Alongside leadership, we:
facilitated conversations that crystalized and articulated UKirk SMU's vision
aligned potential projects with organizational values in a way that resonates with potential donors
laid the groundwork for ongoing communications related to developing a case for a capital campaign
created spaces for relationship-building and strengthening partnerships in common cause
Phase II: annual giving + fundraising
After an invigorating feasibility study, we recommended that UKirk SMU establish an annual giving program. An intentional and robust fundraising infrastructure is essential for the success of potential capital campaigns, and this infrastructure also creates meaningful opportunities for community and donor engagement.
Equipped with data generated by feasibility work, and after analyzing UKirk SMU's giving data, we:
created a 12-month fundraising plan
organized events for individual and congregational donors to experience the power of the UKirk SMU community
prepared for one-on-one invitations to pledge to the UKirk SMU community over both an annual and multi-year period
created a thank you rubric which engages fundraising committee, board and staff
implemented an of year-end campaign
planned a gala fundraising event with volunteers and staff
New York Aikikai
How do we honor our legacy while planning for the future?
Phase I: annual campaign
New York Aikikai has been a center for this beautiful martial art for more than fifty years. For their community to continue to thrive and to adhere to city regulations, their school needs a variety of improvements. We saw the need for a capital campaign, but first, we knew it was essential to establish a fundraising base.
In the middle of laying this foundation, the aikido community experienced a great loss: the first chief instructor of the New York Aikikai passed away in early 2023. Fundraising generally and capital campaigns specifically are deeply linked to who a community is, who they have been, and who they are becoming. Grief, of course, plays a part in all of this. We walked alongside leadership as they navigated reflections on their community’s identity, and helped them strengthen their bonds with each other as they moved into a new era.
When we first started working with the New York Aikikai, there wasn't a history of strong annual campaigns. When done well, annual campaigns thread the needle between donors motivations and giving, and also train leadership to communicate, organize and ask. Annual campaigns train fundraising muscles for capital campaigns. Prior to launching a capital campaign, we ran two annual campaigns.
Phase II: feasibility
On the heels of the pandemic, we conducted a feasibility study, which continued to thread the needle between motivation and giving. We communicated the great care that this community has for each other through:
creating a case statement
interviewing and surveying individuals throughout the world
making recommendations not only for an appropriate goal and timeline, but also for necessary changes in infrastructure to ensure long-term success.
onboarding a new database, procedures for thanking, and more regular communication and transparency
Phase III: solicitation
As we were preparing to begin the solicitation portion of the campaign, the school’s beloved chief instructor and leader Yoshimitsu Yamada Sensei passed away. After a few months of adjusting to the new normal and hosting a memorial service that drew people from all over the world, we started up again.
New fundraising goals were set, leadership recruited, and we utilized the legacy of Yamada Sensei as a way for people to honor their relationship with the dojo, while looking squarely forward to the strong promise that the future holds for this community. Finishing the campaign at the end of January 2024, we raised funds from individuals, dojos and communities in 14 countries. The organization surpassed their primary and stretch goals, and exceeded everyone's expectations.
Phase IV: new website
Coming out of the gate with such strength in 2024 we turned our attention to a new website. Between the community having been gathered in new ways through the capital campaign, and the expectations for strengthened communications, we translated much of the learnings from the campaign into a brand new, interactive website.
Phase V: maintenance of website + communications
We continue to maintain this site, and manage New York Aikikai’s communications.
Good Samaritan Episcopal Church
How does a feasibility study create a healthy capital campaign?
Phase I: listening
In the midst of the pandemic, the Episcopal Church of the Good Samaritan was asking crucial questions about their identity. As the congregation experienced online worship and virtual community, parishioners were reflecting what was of value and remained true over a changing season. Through a parish-wide listening phase we:
implemented a process for all voices to be heard
identified and defined the core values of the faith community
created a core filter for making decisions together
trained the leadership on how to use the filter across the organization.
In addition to identifying core values, the strategic visioning process prepared the congregation for a capital campaign as it provided a process for asking what it means to be a good neighbor in their context.
Phase II: feasibility
For some time, members of Good Sam dreamed of engaging in capital improvements. In the spring of 2023, they engaged in a feasibility study to determine the level of support for a proposed campaign. They wanted to move forward with the support of the congregation and, not having done a capital campaign in more than two decades, wanted to make sure they knew the:
level of awareness of the proposed plans within the parish
level of support for moving forward with a capital campaign
level of engagement by the congregation with the projects and their perception of priority
realistic and feasible goals should a campaign move forward
The results of our feasibility study strongly suggested that Good Sam move forward, and also provided insights into the congregation that would be invaluable to running a healthy capital campaign and to Good Sam's overall strategy for fundraising going forward.
Phase III: solicitation
With the feasibility study as as our infrastructure, we moved into the solicitation phase with confidence. In the fall of 2023, Good Sam launched Assurance of Things Hoped For, a capital campaign with a goal of $1,203,071. Leadership and volunteers invited gifts while also making sure to keep the congregation informed and engaged, and the process transparent.
In January 2024, Good Sam raised $1,305,155. They surpassed the goal the feasibility study pointed us toward, and just as importantly, they strengthened relationships and inspired the congregation to imagine new possibilities for love, active caring, and servanthood. A healthy capital campaign by all of our standards.
First Congregational Church
Who have we been? Who are we now? Where are we going?
Strategy + vision
First Congregational Church is engaged in a series of transitions in leadership, in organization, in ministry styles and goals. With robust community assets, they are moving into a model of church that is more community-focused with plans to utilize their property for the needs of the surrounding area.
We worked with leadership to help them articulate their core values and purpose, utilizing this to transform the ways they are organized and engage in relationships. Together, we explored options for property development, and laid the foundation to establish a community hub. To accomplish all of this, we:
led a retreat for leadership
conducted interviews
wrote and hosted a survey and analyzed data
engaged in congregational change through a month on-site
led 3 congregational town hall meetings
conducted interviews of community partners to see how the congregation and its space usage was viewed externally
analyzed the building and property for more efficient and effective usage
worked with a potential developer, and analyzed city planning documents to create building strategy
As part of their month on-site at First Congregational Church, Mieke and Dave both preached.
Sycamore Collaborative
What’s the path from food pantry to food justice?
Phase I: communications audit
Serving Schenectady County in upstate New York, Sycamore Collaborative (formerly Schenectady Inner City Ministries, or SICM) has been a lifeline in a time of increasing food insecurity and an inspiration for community engagement to volunteers and clients alike. Embracing their decision to become intentionally interfaith, we walked alongside the organization to look across all its communications to understand more clearly what they want to say, to whom, when and how.
In our communications audit, we:
reviewed all current communications
conducted key interviews
led a retreat among organizational leaders and key staff
organized and analyzed data
reviewed staffing capacity
made recommendations and provided reflective language to move the organization forward
Phase II: strategic plan, renaming + rebranding process
As our communications audit concluded, we entered Phase II. In this iteration of our work, we:
articulated core values
created a strategic filter for decision-making
collaboratively created a far-reaching strategic plan
created a new visual identity, name, and website
Allies in Arts
How do we go from start-up to long-lasting change?
Coaching: strategy + vision, fundraising
Mieke consulted one-on-one with the Executive Director to help create a solid infrastructure for growth and sustainability. Together, they worked on:
articulating money narratives
review of organizational structure with recommendations
engaging in organizational changes
Synod of Alberta and the Northwest
Are we spending our money on the right things?
Fundraising, strategy + vision
A Synod in the Presbyterian Church of Canada that covers a wide geographic region, they came to us to assess their needs and priorities, and to suggest a way forward based on this understanding. We conducted a financial and missional audit of two areas of their ministry with recommendations for how to proceed. In our work, we:
recruited and worked with a core team
did a comprehensive document review
conducted interviews throughout the province
created a comprehensive report with findings and recommendations
St. Stephen’s Episcopal Church
How do we fund capital projects for our fast-growing parish?
Phase I: listening
As St. Stephen's continues to live faithfully into the commandment to love their neighbors as themselves, they've begun to burst at the seams. To support them in understanding how best to accommodate their growth, we engaged in a listening phase in which we asked the congregation critical discernment questions.
After three months of congregational conversations, St. Stephen's successfully articulated how their building and plant allow them to live into their identity of being a house of prayer for all people, and just as importantly, how their building and plant limit them from living into this identity.
Phase II: feasibility
To test the level of support for projects named during the listening phase, we moved into working on a feasibility study with St. Stephen's. We conducted personal interviews as well as a congregation-wide survey, and our analysis of the results — both quantitatively and qualitatively — provided leadership with data to answer these tough questions:
what projects do you prioritize? what projects are less of a priority?
what is the level of support for a capital campaign, both financially and volunteer-wise?
what are your opinions about debt?
African Dream Academy Foundation
How do we raise money for a life-changing school, from a world away?
Phase I: audit + retreat
After receiving a grant for board development, our team was hired to conduct a development audit and lead a board fundraising retreat. During our audit and retreat, we:
reviewed fundraising procedures
reviewed thanking procedures
interviewed donors
analyzed donor data to understand growth potential
wrote comprehensive report with recommendations
led fundraising retreat to present findings and work on money narratives
Phase II: implementation
Taking the results and recommendations from our audit work, we led them through a 6-month process to revamp their fundraising efforts. During the implementation phase, we:
created annual fundraising timeline
wrote and designed case materials to match donor motivations heard during Phase I
wrote and designed a donor website
trained volunteers
All Souls
How do we speak transformation?
Communications
All Souls is dedicated to the possibilities inherent in each person, the connections that sustain us in good times and bad, and the transformation of ourselves and the world.
We completed a communications audit to answer these simple yet critical questions:
How do you communicate to the wider world?
What do you say?
How do you say it?
To whom?
Their answers reveal powerful new ways of communicating their robust offerings to their congregants and the world.
Arlington Presbyterian Church
How can we make decisions based on our values instead of on anxiety about money?
Fundraising + vision
After years of faithful discernment, Arlington Presbyterian was challenged with a new three-pronged vision: to create affordable housing, to be a place of crossroads and connection, and to nurture disciples of Jesus Christ. APC was called to sell its building and land to the Arlington Partnership for Affordable Housing (APAH) in order to build Gilliam Place, a 173-unit affordable housing apartment community on the site of our previous building on Columbia Pike. This vision was shaped by the stories of their neighbors, in particular their struggle to connect within the community and to find affordable housing in South Arlington. As one church member recalls, “the call to create affordable housing was bigger than the old building itself – so, the walls came down.”
We started working with Arlington Presbyterian in the wake of this major change and identity shift for Arlington Presbyterian Church. In the fall of 2020, we:
lead a retreat to explore their money story and release anxiety in the system
write an intensive recap report with extensive recommendations.
facilitate a strategic thinking process to identify core values
create a strategic filter rooted in core values for decision making
work with leadership to develop a MOU with the judicatory body for future money considerations
engage in ongoing coaching to provide professional support for ongoing culture changes around money.
Currently we are walking alongside them to implement recommendations, including coaching on the budget process, financial policies and procedures, a financial screen and rubric, and writing of a Lenten Bible study with the topic of What does God say about poor people and rich people?
Rev. Ashley Goff joined us for our webinar on strategic filters in 2022. Check it out below!
Calvary Episcopal Church
How are we leaders in the neighborhood at the intersection of tradition and newness?
Listening + feasibility
Together, we helped Calvary discern how their space reflects their core values and what is needed for the congregation to live into their collective vision. We created and led a listening process where guided conversations fostered deeper relationships and capital improvement projects were identified. We then engaged in a feasibility study, concluded that there was indeed a campaign to conduct and are currently in the midst of implementation of soliciting gifts.
Chicago, United, Eden (CUE)
Why support theological education as a collective?
Communications + fundraising
Chicago, United and Eden Seminaries of the United Church of Christ, (CUE) receives financial support from local midwest congregations through a shared giving system. Working together, we’ll explore ways to encourage giving through this channel, looking at messaging for appeals, coordinating stewardship, and crafting acknowledgements for congregational gifts.
At a time when leadership of emerging seminarians is so important in the changing church before us, we are thrilled to have helped to ensure that funding continues to flow toward the source of theological education and formation.
Christ Church Episcopal Cathedral
Who is the little church on the circle?
Communication
We worked with Christ Church to create communication strategies and implementation.
Christ Episcopal Church
How do we recover from serial disasters?
Phase I: feasibility
Christ Church came to us with meaty goals for a capital campaign, but with the need to test out those goals through a feasibility study. We led the congregation through the study by writing and developing case materials, interviewing prospective donors, and facilitating an online survey. We were pleased to find feasibility and are have now completed the implementation of their capital campaign.
Covenant Network of Presbyterians
How do we live out our covenant today and tomorrow?
Communications + identity
An organization's internal work along with a changing landscape can often impact their overall identity. Following shifts in their denomination's environment, we worked with the Covenant Network to articulate their verbal identity. We then successfully paired these words with images by creating a new logo and visual identity.
Endless Field Band
How can music help save the planet?
A bit out of our wheelhouse, Endless Field is a purpose-driven band who sought funding for an album they planned on recording in the wilderness.
They wanted to learn how to fundraise for this project, and we guided them to find a fiscal sponsor, write case materials, research potential donors, and approach those donors for funding. As a result of our work together, their album recording was funded and then released in 2020. You can listen to ALIVE IN THE WILDERNESS here — all proceeds from downloads are donated to the National Resources Defense Council (NRDC) to fight the climate crisis.
As part of our work together, we engaged in an intensive time of exploring personal narratives around money and the stumbling blocks that prevented them from claiming their gifts and talents through fundraising.
Episcopal Church of Heavenly Rest
How do you run a campaign with bare cupboards?
Fundraising + identity
Heavenly Rest was in need of interim design and fundraising support as they were transitioning staff, and Vandersall Collective was happy to help.
Episcopal Diocese of Indianapolis
How can we be of service?
Communications, identity, strategy + vision
We worked with the diocese to lead a restructuring retreat for their Executive Council, as well as implementing their vision for the future through design work.
First Presbyterian Church
What does the way we raise money say about us?
Fundraising
First Presbyterian sought a development audit to help them understand how their fundraising processes lined up with their members desires and needs. After leading a retreat on money narratives, reviewing processes and conducting a series of interviews, we created a lengthy report with findings and recommendations.
First Presbyterian Church
How does money pull us down or raise us up?
Echoing Jesus and his disciples, First Presbyterian Church, Rahway, NJ gathers to worship and joins in fellowship. creating community for all who come. This strengthens us to go out into the world to minister to the vulnerable. Emboldened by the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus, we work and pray for a world where all people can live in peace.
We were asked to lead First Church through a process of education and discernment to untangle their complex relationship with money. Through multiple retreats, homework and coaching, we were able to explore money narratives, both personally as well as congregationally, and then provide the Session with a detailed report of our process with concrete recommendations for their future leadership.
Episcopal Church of the Holy Communion
How does our building reflect who we are?
Feasibility
To prepare to do a feasibility study for Holy Communion, we developed case materials and through this process, helped define the goals of the campaign.
Then, alongside leadership and volunteers, we conducted interviews and facilitated the process for a congregational-wide survey. Once we found that there was feasibility for the campaign, we successfully led the congregation through their capital campaign, exceeding their goal!
Judson Memorial Church
How do we raise money to provide access to the neighborhood?
Fundraising
We are pleased to have engaged in a partnership with the Heller Fundraising Group to support Judson Memorial Church in New York City as they consider a capital campaign to make their building more accessible. Judson supports countless community arts, justice and religious groups in the thriving Washington Square neighborhood. So often it is hard to know where to start with a project of this size, and we’re helping them do just that: start!
Knox Presbyterian Church
What happens when Sunday morning doesn’t look like the neighborhood?
Knox Presbyterian is an inclusive Christian atmosphere for spiritual nourishment and caring fellowship. Together with Parish Properties, through a series of interviews and retreats, we created a report with recommendations to help them discover how to become a sustainable community hub. We then worked to create and implement a season of fundraising plans.
Leo Baeck Institute
How do we organize to raise money more effectively?
Fundraising
Vandersall Collective guided LBI through the creation of a major donor fundraising program, including event management and donor management.
Metro New York Synod (ELCA)
How do we unite across culture and geography?
The Metro New York Synod came to us with a few short months to spare before their Reformation 500 Service at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine. They needed a skilled event planner who could quickly onramp their work as they knew time was running out. In addition to needing help, the scope of the event kept growing!
The event grew from an expected audience of a few hundred to over 1,000. This included ecumenical guests from throughout the breadth and depth of the Christian tradition. In addition, liturgical planning was needed with two choirs, three ensembles, and dozens more liturgical participants. We coordinated countless details and subcontractors to provide a seamless experience for the guests who came and allowed the liturgy to shine through. A powerful event moving forward the ecumenical community committed to unity in Christ, we were proud to have played a part in creating this memorable night of a lifetime.
Middle Collegiate Church
How do you raise money in a complex financial system?
Middle Collegiate Church is a celebrating, culturally diverse, inclusive and growing community of faith where all people are welcomed just as they are as they come through the door. As a teaching congregation that celebrates the arts, our ministries include rich and meaningful worship, care and education that nurture the mind, body and spirit, social action which embraces the global community, and participation in an interfaith dialogue for the purpose of justice and reconciliation.
At a crossroads of funding sources and with a need for a plan, we conducted a development audit, provided an annual calendar and implemented their year-end campaign.
More Light Presbyterians
How do you bring the power of a legacy to life in today’s church?
More Light Presbyterians engages over 230 congregations and thousands of individuals in the Presbyterian Church (USA), enabling Presbyterians to lead LGBTQIA+ service and advocacy in communities nationwide. More Light’s mission has always been to empower and equip individuals and congregations to live into their welcome for LGBTQIA+ people.
We worked with them to increase their individual donor program, and set them up for many years of fundraising success. Through review of data, assistance in implementing recommendations, intensive training, and walking alongside the staff and the board, we are excited for what is to come for MLP.
Music that Makes Community
How do we go from start-up to grown-up?
A non-profit organization working with ecumenical communities and leaders, MMC empowers and liberates communities’ spiritual life through singing.
Case Study
When Paul Vasile took the reins as Executive Director, Music That Makes Community needed to raise funds urgently and quickly. A small, but engaged and energetic Board, took up the challenge to envision with Vandersall Collective how to bring the organizational skills and larger vision of their Executive Director to life in vibrant new ways.
How do we tell our story in a way that will foster active participation and financial engagement?
What are our priorities as an organization?
What are the new horizons we can explore as we invite people to support us?
VEHICLES FOR CHANGE
Fundraising—A customized fundraising initiative that incorporated the small pool of major donors and the wide-ranging group of individuals and organizations that had experienced the power of the ministry of Music That Makes Community over the years.
NEW DIRECTIONS
Collateral Materials—A fresh new face for a new era in the life of MMC, communicated in clean, bright, high contrast visuals, and accessible words to reflect an organization that is all about human connection
Board Member Training—Working with Board members in the basic mechanics of donor cultivation and funding requests, Vandersall Collective planted seeds that would outlive our hands on engagement
Donor Strategy—Creating a tracking system, tailored to the donor base, needs, and vision of the organization, along with communication and note-taking features to support tracking and maintaining relationships
Major Donor Campaign—Vandersall Collective then conceptualized, wrote, designed and launched a fall campaign, telling the story of the organization through the testimonies of those who had received MMC’s services and requesting support. We seized this opportunity to increase the grassroots supporters and also to increase the number of larger donors as well as opening the way for multiple conversations with prospective board members.
Grass Roots Cultivation—By connecting with those who had received MMC’s services, we not only gleaned beautiful stories, we helped to build another, broad-based constituency of individual giving and engagement for the future vision.
ON THE HORIZON
Having exceeded fundraising goals and met our quick timeline, we continue to work toward a bright and creative new era of transformation and community through music.
Nevelson Chapel
What do art and church have to do with God and the city?
Nevelson Chapel is the only remaining, permanent, fully intact sculptural environment by Louise Nevelson. Nine wall-mounted sculptures, a tranquil white-on-white presentation accented with gold-leaf and enhanced by the play of shadow and light from a single window, the Chapel is an incomparable example of this 20th-century art form which is intended to involve or encompass visitors. Nevelson was instrumental in the conception and introduction of the form, which “sought to break down the historical dichotomy between life and art.”
Vandersall Collective has served in many forms as we work together to restore and renew the Chapel. We are integrated into all aspects of the Chapel life. Together we manage all events and communications, including the case materials, social media, eblasts and the website, and serve as the primary fundraising council. In addition to advising the Chapel project, we have created systems and structures for fundraising administration, and are deeply embedded in the enactment of them running smoothly. We continue to implement communication strategies through the curation of their Instagram account.
“Our campaign isn't simply raising money. We are building relationships, recalibrating our culture and renewing our mission. Mieke and her team are integrated into every aspect with competency, dedication and heart.”
— The Rev. Jared Stahler, Nevelson Chapel
Not So Churchy
How do we reflect the core of who we are?
Not So Churchy is a place of healing and hope, where queerness and curiosity expand the spiritual journey beyond boxes and binaries. This eclectic community also happens to have been started by Mieke, and is where she currently serves. We engage as their regular designer, including the beautification of annual reports and the website that serves as a spiritual home for this geographically diverse community.
Park Avenue Christian Church
The project’s started. How do we raise the money?
The community at The Park is on a mission and has a vision – a vision for a more just, sustainable, vibrant and growing community that has a broad impact on our city, our nation and our world. They believe that the church should be a place where we come to worship, fellowship and be sent out as ministers to do the work that God has called us to do — in our homes, our workplaces, our volunteer organizations, and in the world.
We served as primary fundraising counsel for the Park as they have prepared to publicly launch their multi-million dollar capital campaign. Through this, we created their case materials, both verbally and visually.
Presbytery of Baltimore
What do we do with our old buildings?
We are delighted to have joined the Presbytery of Baltimore as part of the Thriving Congregations initiative. In partnership with Parish Properties, we led "Reimagining Church: From Buildings to Community—Weaving a fabric of love and care in the neighborhood," with representatives of local congregations who are asking, "How can we be the church in these unsteady and quickly changing times?"
Presbytery of New York City
How do we communicate simply in the most complex city in the world?
The Presbytery of New York City encompasses the geographic boundaries of the City of New York, the five boroughs of the Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, and Staten Island. In their 97 congregations, they welcome nearly 15,000 members in worship, mission, and service to their city and beyond. They are a part of the Presbyterian Church (USA) and the Synod of the Northeast. We created a new website for the Presbytery, increasing communication and transparency throughout their community.
Q Christian Fellowship
How do we stake our claim to the Good News of Christ?
Q Christian Fellowship is an international network of Christians working for fully inclusive Christian community and a world where all people are treated as the beloved children of God. It is their mission to transform attitudes toward LGBTQ (lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender) people and bring about a day when the church is the biggest ally and defender of LGBTQ people rather than a chief opponent.
Q Christian came to us with an urgent need for a new website. After quickly completing a new, beautiful, easy to navigate site, we then began work on a name change, shift in verbal identity, visual implementation including logo and web design, and a short video.
Saint Peter's Church
How do merged congregations become one?
Saint Peter’s Church is a welcoming and diverse evangelical catholic communion nourished by God and publicly engaged with others in creatively shaping life in the city.
Working with the Director of Communications, we helped guide Saint Peter’s in articulating their needs for a new website and then enacting those needs through the creation of a design brief, guidance of verbal articulation, and then implementation through a new, easy to manage, website. We continue to provide regular maintenance support.
Society for the Increase of the Ministry (SIM)
How can scholarships transform the church?
All people and all societies need wise spiritual leadership to inspire, inform and renew our lives. The Society for the Increase of the Ministry (SIM) guarantees the identification and education of outstanding faith leaders whose public imagination and witness matter in our world. SIM is expanding scholarships to increase the positive impact of faith leadership on our common life.
SIM, having served the Episcopal Church since 1857, found themselves at another crossroad with a renewed desire to influence theological education and church leadership for the 21st century. We began our work with SIM through leading the board on a retreat to explore strategic direction, and then then continued our work together through their year-end fundraising efforts, and the creation of a strategic plan and development plan. We continue to provide support through year-end fundraising campaigns.
St. Andrew's Presbyterian Church
How do we raise money in a culture where money is taboo?
At St. Andrew’s, Austin, TX, they try their hardest to be a warm, creative, justice-oriented community, rooted in the Gospel of Jesus Christ.
St. Andrews’s came to us wanting to test out their goals for a capital campaign, which would enable the congregation to live into their mission and values to serve their neighbors through significant building improvements. We conducted their feasibility study and created their case materials, conducted in-person interviews and facilitated their on-line survey. We then wrote a detailed report with recommendations for living into their goals.
St. John the Evangelist Episcopal Church
How do we meld stewardship with congregational life?
With nearly 500 active members, St. John’s is a diverse, and growing parish, deeply committed to outreach both in the city and around the world. They are home to thriving youth and children’s ministries, celebrate an excellent music program for all ages,. welcome all people into our community of faith and find great joy in being together, in worship, in service, and in play.
St. John’s came to us seeking coaching for their staff person with the responsibility of Stewardship Programming. In order to prepare her for a successful campaign and the parish for a successful future, we worked together to create a long-lasting structure which includes both fundraising but also a healthy and spiritually fulfilling relationship with money. We continue to serve St. John’s through occasional coaching.
St. Lydia's Dinner Church
How do we raise money the first time? The second time?
St. Lydia's Dinner Church is a progressive, LGBTQ-affirming congregation in the Gowanus neighborhood of Brooklyn, New York, working to dispel isolation, reconnect neighbors, and subvert the status quo.
Case Study
St. Lydia’s Dinner Church is a new Lutheran congregation that gathers around tables. They began with denominational support from the Evangelical Lutheran Church of America and the Episcopal Church, in addition to a few major donors. As their community grew, they moved into their own space, worshiping on Sunday morning and evening and Monday evening, and providing co-working space for entrepreneurs during weekdays day which not only dispels isolation but provides a revenue stream. Their congregation is now supported by congregants themselves, denominational grants, rentals, co-working and major donors who find value and satisfaction in supporting the congregation’s mission and vision.
In anticipation of waning denominational grant funding, the Vandersall Collective was contracted to create and implement their major donor (Chef’s Table) program. Working with Emily Scott, their pastor, we conceptualized and wrote major donor collateral materials, assisted in the creation of major donor tracking process and annual fundraising calendar, and organized and implemented major donor cultivation events, one from afar in the Bay Area and the other in New York City.
We were thrilled that the major donor program attracted new donors and raised the commitment of existing donors, and that the leadership of St. Lydia’s now has a structure to implement moving forward.
However, perhaps the most favorite part of our work together was coaching Emily and their Leadership Table and Fundraising Team. Together we learned how to communicate pastorally with and empower millennials in their giving. We led multiple fundraising trainings where we explored theological and emotional responses to money and fundraising in the church, invigorating congregant volunteers to engage both outside donors and their fellow congregants in generous giving. Mieke also preached at St. Lydia’s and the led a conversation with the congregation at large in preparation for their stewardship season.
St. Paul's Episcopal Cathedral
How do we listen to align our values with our building project?
St. Paul’s Cathedral serves as a center of transformative love, faith and service: an inclusive, Christ-centered community that welcomes all people on their journey of faith.
To plan for a comprehensive capital campaign to help their physical structure reflect their values and mission, we led a period of listening and stakeholder engagement.
St. Paul's Episcopal Church
How do we raise capital funds on the heels of a pandemic?
St Paul's Episcopal Church, Franklin, TN is the state's oldest Episcopal Church. A community rich in history, St. Paul's is now asking how its space can best be utilized to live more fully into God’s vision for the future. It's our job to work with the congregation to conduct a Feasibility Study, which will help them determine what resources are available and how the energy and passion of their community can be harnessed to help their vision come to life.
We are delighted to have worked with as partners committed to raising funds as part of a ministry that responds in meaningful ways to the needs and possibilities around them. Together we engaged in a feasibility study and a revamp of annual giving during the pandemic year of 2020. We then implemented a capital campaign and are thrilled that they exceeded their fundraising goals!
Sunnyside
How do we bring a saggy gift (building) to life?
Sunnyside is a United Methodist space in Portland, OR which has not had a faith community present for years. Working with a gifted church planter who is currently using the space, and who has been empowered to work out a plan for the transformation and upkeep of the space, we partnered with Parish Properties to refine their mission and vision, strengthen community partnerships and explore potential development of the building.
Synod of the Northeast
Who needs a synod?
The General Assembly of the PCUSA asked synods around the country to answer the question of why they should exist. We worked with Synod of the Northeast to come up with their response.
“We are glad to be working again with Vandersall Collective on branding our biennial worship, learning and fellowship gathering. Working with Vandersall Collective is accessing creativity, diligence, and passion commitment to radical welcome and pursuit of justice.”
— The Rev. Dr. Amaury Tañón-Santos, Synod of the Northeast
Several years ago, the Synod of the Northeast of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) was responding to a mandate from its national body to examine its effectiveness and purpose. While being open to complete disbandedment, they learned that they have particular gifts to share, and that the diversity of the gathered community was too important to lose. To emphasize the gifts of this gathered body, they worked to refocus their energies, flipping the balance so that gathering received more emphasis than governing, allowing the gathering time to be filled with energy and the governing time to be filled with purpose.
In three key areas, we have been honored to work with the Synod to help implement its new strategic vision.
COMMUNICATION
We created and implemented a cohesive and cross-platform communication plan in consultation with the Synod, and as a result of a communications audit. The website was used as a community hub where information was shared clearly and effectively. A video was created to communicate the personalities and the impact the Synod is having on the life of its constituents. An eblast schedule and template (both visual and content) was created to further tell those stories, driving traffic back to the website. Finally, we created special branding for their two biennial conferences, known as Come to the Table.
To effectively communicate their vision, and the new ways of engagement that come out of that vision, their website needed to become a vital location centralizing communication and provide opportunity for community-building. After completing a communications audit and report, we took their existing logo and vision, flushed out a verbal and visual brand identity, and created a new, easy to update website.
To communicate with their constituency in between events, as well as to communicate the weight and importance of their work with current and potential donors, we created a robust package of print materials. Their Robert L. Washington Scholars & Fellows program was established to provide leadership opportunities for young and/or people of color, and we also created a gorgeous and hefty annual report.
The Synod also needed a way to personally and persuasively communicate their vision and warmth to the people in their large geographic area without physically having to be present. Our creative team reflected their story back through a short video. Working with a team from the Synod we wrote a script, gathered leaders from throughout the Synod together for a day-long shoot, and then edited together a video currently used in their local communities, and at fundraising events.
Stories of hope and innovation that exemplified the Synod’s deepened purposed needed to be shared persuasively and effectively. We created a communication schedule and guidelines, integrating the website, social media and new eblast templates to reflect the new brand identity. We also worked with the staff to train them to take their design templates and do it on their own.
Finally, as the Synod's focus shifted to gathering, the first non-governing event was a major undertaking. Our services were contracted to help the planning team create and execute a hospitable, organized experience for their guests. We took the branding platform and guidelines and implemented them through the creation of a registration process and conference booklet. We also worked with the worship team to align our worship time with the new vision of the Synod. Mieke Vandersall, Derrick McQueen, Paul Vasile, and Larissa Kwong-Abazia of the Vandersall Collective were instrumental in making this event a success.
GRANT-MAKING
In their process of re-visioning, the Synod reallocated significant funding to support innovative ministry within their geographical bounds. When we began our work with the Synod they asked for help in reconstructing their grant applications, application process, and review process. Using best practices, putting more trust in the applicants, and encouraging them to explain their needs in their own words, we first wrote a report after speaking with various past grantees with recommendations for change and then worked with the Mission and Ministry Commission (their Board-equivalent) to refresh their process and encourage a more mutual relationship between the applicants and their Synod. The stories of the applicants were also the basis of our communication strategy.
FUNDRAISING
With so many new people, congregations and organizations seeking funding from the Synod, and the heightened communication about the granting opportunities, the generous funding set aside in the Synod’s budget was being spent faster than ever before. In order to understand how best to raise funds, we completed a development audit, and then began a robust major-donor program, integrating the opportunity for giving on the website, organizing multiple cultivation events throughout the northeast, and launching the Synod's inaugural year-end campaign highlighting the impact of the grants made to innovative ministries.
Kaleidoscapes
How do we say goodbye gracefully?
The Kaleidoscapes is an eco-theatre company dedicated to performing accessible storytelling and facilitating experiential learning in nontraditional spaces with those most affected by the climate crisis. We worked with them to create systems of organization. Through our process we helped them come to the decisions that the right choice was closing shop, and led them through a healthy process to do so.
The Vine
What is the appeal of progressive campus ministry?
The Vine NYC is a network of open, inviting campus ministries in New York City where all students are welcome. They are college and graduate students from institutions across the city who together are trying to figure out how to live in better relationship with God, one another and creation.
The past many years has seen a decrease in funding of campus ministry programs. We worked with The Vine to kick-start their fundraising efforts by conducting a mini-development audit, writing and designing case materials, analyzing their donor list, training their board and leadership, accompanying their leadership on “asks,” and organizing their first-ever major donor cultivation and ask event.
Trinity's SAFH (Services and Food for the Homeless)
How do we get from hand-to-mouth to a table always set?
SAFH provides a reliable source of food for those who are hungry, in the lower east side of Manhattan. In 2020 the need they filled skyrocketed, and we were able to provide some pro-bono work to raise funds to help them continue their work in the midst of COVID. In 2020 they distributed 200,000 meals.
Trinity Episcopal Church
How do we raise money when we’re not quite ready?
Trinity Church is a congregation in the suburbs of the Twin Cities. In order to meet the programmatic needs of the congregation, the leadership needed to increase the budget. We worked with them to establish an aspirational budget, grow its major donor base, create annual material, and ultimately meet its goal by raising almost $50,000 in increased funding.
The next year we were hired to conduct a feasibility study and at the same time successfully run their 2021 annual campaign with a 20% budgetary increase.
West End Church
How do we show people who we really are?
Phase I: communications audit
West End Church on the Upper West Side of Manhattan is a community with deep roots, curious spirits, and hearts set on God’s way of justice and peace. They want their neighbors, and the whole world, to know what they're up to, why it matters, and how to be involved, especially in this time when connection and community are so vitally important.
After leading a robust communications audit including a strategic retreat, series of interviews and a survey, we created a framework authentic to them through which to view their communication strategy. We then rebranded West End Church through a new logo and communication system, and built and launched their new website. We continue to provide on-going communications support as they live into their new look and articulated identity.
Phase II: fundraising
Alongside our on-going communications support, we work with West End to develop annual campaigns that reflect their culture, identity, theology of giving, and goals. Our work together has included:
creating opportunities for leaders to reflect on money narratives
creating and implementing segmentation of giving data to consider appropriate strategies
increasing volunteerism through training, ongoing coaching, and celebration
developing compelling communication pieces for multiples audiences and special occasions
Westminster Presbyterian Church
How does our staffing, working and structure reflect who we want to be?
Westminster Presbyterian Church is a congregation in West Hartford, CT that found itself at a crossroads. They needed help exploring what worship means to them, as well as exploration of staffing models. We worked with them by providing a congregational assessment tool, and then using that as well as a staffing audit and worship audit to provide recommendations for their life moving forward. We then coached the pastor in implementing our recommendations.
Case Study
A traditional church must find a path between the comforts of tradition and the challenges of deeper engagement in spiritual growth and community life.
Who are we as a congregation?
How do we relate to our community?
How do we re-invigorate a once glorious music program?
How do we attract people to worship?
Do we have the right structure to support our work and worship?
How do we stay relevant and serve God fully?
VEHICLES FOR CHANGE
Congregational Assessment Tool (CAT)—Surveying beliefs and priorities, rather than likes and preferences, the CAT reveals aspects of congregational identity that lay the foundation for meaningful, sustainable growth and change.
Staff Audit—Focusing on the needs of the congregation and its larger context, staffing is aligned and re-framed in life-giving ways that reflect the true priorities of the church’s mission and vision. No more structure for structure’s sake.
Worship and Music Audit and Modeling—Coming out of the choir loft and revisiting the relationships among the elements and entry points that deepen and expand opportunities for worship, the audit, along with coaching and guidance, breathes new life into the center of congregational experience.
NEW DIRECTIONS
Congregational self-understanding leads to new ways of being that are authentic and full of possibility.
Staffing that reflects the life and mission of the church, rather than serving a structure that no longer fits, frees church leadership to be more creative and engaged.
Breaking a mold of passive and performative traditions, worship and music is integrated with congregational and community life, taking full advantage of space and time, infusing life and opening toward the movement of the Spirit
ON THE HORIZON
Outward facing priorities that look beyond whether we’re keeping the congregation happy.
Intergenerational spiritual engagement and integration with day-to-day life.
Diversity and creativity in music, art, use of space, conversation, and worship patterns.
Working with Vandersall Collective was like finding good friends. They got us!